Recent Volatility in the Public Stock Markets
The past several weeks have delivered a dramatic reminder of how quickly sentiment can shift in the public stock markets. Investors have faced sharp declines, historic rebounds, and an ongoing sense of uncertainty as policy changes, economic data, and global events continue to shape the investment landscape.
What Drove the Recent Volatility?
The most significant catalyst for the latest bout of volatility was President Trump’s announcement of sweeping tariffs—dubbed “Liberation Day” tariffs—at the start of April. This policy surprise sent shockwaves through the markets, causing the S&P 500 to plummet nearly 12% in just the first eight days of the month, compounding losses from March. The market’s “fear index,” the Cboe Volatility Index (VIX), spiked above 40, marking one of the most extreme readings since 2020. However, the volatility was not solely the result of trade policy. The sell-off in mega-cap technology stocks, ongoing concerns about U.S. economic growth, and rising interest rates all contributed to the risk-off environment. Surveys also revealed a dip in consumer confidence, while initial unemployment claims ticked higher, fueling concerns about the resilience of the economic recovery.
A Swift Reversal
Just as quickly as markets fell, they rebounded. On April 9, President Trump announced a 90-day suspension of most tariffs to allow for further trade negotiations. This triggered a historic single-day surge in the S&P 500—up 10%, the fourth largest one-day gain in its history. The VIX rapidly declined from above 40 to below 20 in a record-setting 21 days, signaling a return to more typical levels of volatility. By the end of April, the U.S. stock market had recaptured most of its losses, with valuations returning to levels seen before the tariff announcement.
Where Do We Stand Now?
As of the end of April, the U.S. stock market was trading at an 8% discount to fair value, according to Morningstar’s composite valuations. Energy stocks have become increasingly attractive, while value and core sectors are recommended for overweight positions. However, the current calm may be temporary. The deadline for the 90-day tariff pause is July 8, and uncertainty remains high as trade negotiations continue without a finalized agreement in sight.
Looking Ahead: More Volatility Likely
Analysts caution that more volatility is probable in the coming months. The economy is expected to experience distortions from pre-tariff purchasing, supply chain disruptions, and a projected slowdown in real economic growth. Interest rate uncertainty and political developments—especially with one party controlling all branches of government—add further unpredictability to the outlook.
What Should Investors Do?
We consistently warn investors of over-exposure to the public markets. The public markets typically have low risk-adjusted returns compared to the alternative market. All of Waverley’s investments are backed by secured assets and therefore do not trade at discounts to fair value. Alternative assets are valued based on the intrinsic value of the underlying assets, not the vagaries of the retail investor. This also results in low volatility of share/unit prices.